I don't always agree with the critics. In fact, I am often a lone voice in the fashion wilderness. Case in point: The Chanel dress Sarah Jessica parker wore to the 2010 Academy Awards. Social media was literally buzzing about the gorgeous gown. But I thought it looked .. not quite right. Who am I to argue with Karl Lagerfeld or SJP or Carrie Bradshaw? But regardless of my lack of credentials, I didn't love the dress. We can agree to disagree. So, although you may disagree, and probably will, here are my awards (both good and bad) for the past 15 Academy award best actress winners:
Most Disappointing
Gwyneth Paltrow in Ralph Lauren. The pink ballgown Gwyneth wore when she won best actress for Shakespeare in Love just didn't fit her quite right.. or something. I know.. everyone adored that dress, and it seems like blasphemy not to, but I think that it was all wrong for her - she has such a willowy frame and would have looked so much more elegant in something that emphasized that. (I also thought that Cate Blanchett should have won for Elizabeth but that's another story).
Most Dated
Hilary Swank wore Randolph Duke when she won the Oscar for Best Actress in Boys Don't Cry.I love Hilary, but the dress just seemed wrong. It wasn't that I hated the dress, it just wasn't very modern - and I don't mean in a cool, retro way, but in a kind of .. , I had this one left over from when I almost got nominated in the early 90's way.
Most Improved
Meryl Streep in Lanvin. Meryl is perfect as an actress, but the day after awards shows, fashion critics avoid mentioning her dresses because they aren't usually well, worth mentioning. But the gold Lanvin dress she wore in 2012, (when she won best actress for her ridiculously spot on portrayal of Margaret Thatcher in Iron Lady) finally made people take notice of her fashion as well as her acting talent.
Best Dress Backs
Back to back winners Charlize Theron in Gucci in 2004 and Hilary Swank in Guy Laroche in 2005.
Bravest Choice
Halle Berry in Elie Saab in 2002 and Reese Witherspoon in Vintage Christian Dior in 2006 - I love both Halle and Reese, and they took chances that paid off. Reese bucked tradition and chose her own vintage Dior gown which I am, of course, a little biased towards. Halle chose a dress from one of my favorite modern day designers, Elie Saab. The oxblood gown with embroidered lace bodice was not only a brave but brilliant choice.
Best Pregnant Star on the Red Carpet Ever
Natalie Portman in Rodarte in 2011. No one should look that beautiful when pregnant!
Ageless Perfection
Helen Mirren pretty much gets it right every time - but she nailed it with the Christian Lacroix gown she wore when she won best actress for The Queen in 2007. I want to be Helen Mirren.
Great Dress but that Hair..
Nicole Kidman in 2003 in Jean Paul Gaultier. Nicole can shine on the red carpet and often does, but the slicked back hair she wore with this gorgeous Gaultier dress dulled her shimmer.
Top Overall Pick
My favorite of the past 15 years has to be Sandra Bullock in Marchesa when she won the best actress oscar for The Blind Side in 2010. Not only was the dress breathtaking, her hair and make up were absolutely perfect. She owned the night.
1999 - Gwyneth Paltrow in Ralph Lauren
2000 - Hillary Swank in Randolph Duke
2001 - Julia Roberts in Valentino
2002 - Halle Berry in Elie Saab
2003 - Nicole Kidman in Jean Paul Gaultier
2004 - Charlize Theron in Gucci
2005 - Hilary Swank in Guy Laroche
2006 - Reese Witherspoon in Vintage Christian Dior
2007 - Helen Mirren in Christian Lacroix
2008 - Marion Cotillard in Jean Paul Gaultier
2009 - Kate Winslet in Yves Saint Laurent
2010 Sandra Bullock in Marchesa
2011 - Natalie Portman in Rodarte
2012 - Meryl Streep in Lanvin
2013 - Jennifer Lawrence in Christian Dior
So, do you agree? What awards would you give to these stars, which disappointed the most and which were your favorites? Go ahead - I can take it!